Ata Pro
Internet Alarm Monitoring
Demise of the Public Switched Telephone Network
For decades, PSTN has been the chosen communication platform for the transmission of alarm signals. Today, many are predicting its days are numbered. Two transmission paths have emerged as the preferred methods of communication between an alarm panel and Monitoring Centre – IP (the Internet) and GSM. This article will examine the pros and cons of each.
GSM Wireless Networks
In today’s high tech world, almost everybody owns a mobile phone. The perception is that GSM networks are very reliable and rarely suffer from network outages. This makes GSM a viable platform for alarm communications and three different technologies can be employed for signal transmission – SMS, Voice and Data. The reliability of SMS varies greatly from country to country and delays in message delivery rule it out from being considered a serious option in countries where messages can often be delayed for many hours. In countries that do not experience such delays, SMS can be a good low cost method of alarm communication, however, it is often not popular with alarm monitoring companies as it opens up the possibility of self monitoring where messages can be sent directly to the end users mobile phone.
The use of a GSM Dialer/Communicator allows an alarm panel modem to dial out and make a phone call to the Monitoring Centre over the GSM network. When a conventional analogue alarm receiver answers the call, an audio/voice channel is opened up and the alarm panel can communicate with the receiver just as it would over a PSTN line. This technology benefits from being alarm protocol independent and industry
experts claim a transmission success rate of somewhere between 80% and 100%.
PROS: Both SMS and Voice benefit from low equipment costs and low network rates.
CONS: SMS and Voice technologies do not allow for the cost efficient supervision of a connection to the Monitoring Centre and often the first anyone gets to know about sabotage or network failure is when a scheduled signal, or worse, an emergency signal fails to arrive.
GPRS Wireless Networks
The use of a GPRS data plan overcomes this problem and allows constant supervision of the connection between the protected premises and the Monitoring Centre. A GPRS device uses the GSM network to achieve an ‘always on’ wireless connection to the Internet. Once connected, it can communicate using Internet Protocols (IP) just like any other Internet enabled device. This allows the sending of regular heartbeats to the monitoring server so that any equipment failure, sabotage or loss of network can be detected within seconds.
GPRS devices do not support audio/voice communications, so any alarm signals using standard protocols such as Ademco Contact ID or Fast Format have to be converted from analogue to digital within the device itself. This is referred to as Dialer Capture. GPRS enabled devices are more expensive than SMS and Voice devices and the cost of data plans vary widely from country to country. Asian countries tend to have very reasonable rates whereas rates in North America are very restrictive.
CONS: All of the GSM technologies are vulnerable to sabotage from a GSM Jammer which can be
used to prevent devices from connecting to the network.
IP Networks (the Internet)
Due to the widespread availability of the Internet, a large number of consumers are turning to voice over IP for voice service. For the continuity of clear telephone calls from human to human it’s a simple case of unplugging your analogue telephone handset from the PSTN line and plugging it into an analogue terminal adapter to make and receive calls over the Internet. The human ear is very forgiving and even though delays and echo in voice conversations can sometimes be off-putting, both parties are usually able to understand each other.
Unfortunately, this is not the case with alarm communications. Somewhere between converting analogue into digital, traveling over the wire and converting digital back to analogue, things like noise and latency are introduced and along with other problems with VoIP networks, can cause alarm communications to fail.
An in depth knowledge of alarm panel protocols, alarm receivers and Internet protocols has made it possible for some solutions providers to allow the use of regular low cost ‘off the shelf’ VoIP ATA’s for the reliable transmission of alarm signals over the Internet. This obviously provides huge cost benefits to both installers and end users as devices can be sourced locally and existing Internet connections can be utilized as the transmission path.
It should be noted that these solutions do not use or rely on the services of a VoIP service provider. A fully controlled connection direct from the VoIP ATA device to the monitoring server effectively creates a private network.
CONS: All fixed wire IP solutions are subject to sabotage from line cut which prevent devices connecting to the network.
Dual Path Signaling
Even trusty old PSTN was not immune from network failure and was definitely prone to line cut attacks. The line cut vulnerability has been removed with the supervised connections incorporated by IP and GPRS solutions but it is clear that even they cannot guarantee 100% network uptime.
With this in mind, many consumers refuse to rely 100% on a single transmission path and insist on a secondary backup path. There are several combinations that can be used to provide a dual path solution with different levels of security. The lowest level dual path solution is provided by using a combination of PSTN and GSM. As PSTN continues to decline and neither path allows for cost efficient network supervision, this is not a future-proof option.
A more popular combination for cost sensitive applications is the use of the Internet as the primary path and GSM Voice as the secondary path. The Internet path benefits from network supervision and the GSM path can take over if the primary path fails. Certain model VoIP ATA’s used in conjunction with GSM dialer have the ability to send signals over the Internet when a panel dials the primary telephone number and over the GSM network when it dials the secondary telephone number.
A similar level of security can be provided by using GPRS as the primary path and PSTN as the secondary path. Some solutions providers claim a dual path capability by using GPRS as the primary path and GSM Voice or SMS as a secondary path. Others claim dual path capability by using two GPRS SIM cards. These claims are somewhat misguided as a GSM jammer will effectively prevent all communications over the GSM network regardless of which method is used. GSM can only ever be treated as a single path even though it allows for 3 different methods (SMS, Voice & GPRS) of transmission.
High security applications demand two independently supervised transmission paths and this is usually achieved by using the Internet as the primary path and GPRS as the secondary path. Both are fully supervised, so even if the primary Internet path fails the system is left with a supervised alternative path.
Some solutions providers claim that by using a combination of broadband Internet, GPRS, GSM, PSTN and Dialup Internet their product supports 5 paths. As both broadband and Dialup Internet generally depend on the availability of a PSTN line and GPRS depends on a GSM connection a more accurate claim would be that such a solution can use 5 different methods of communication over two independent transmission paths. A dual path solution with bells and whistles.
Remote Programming and Audio Verification
If it is important for your company to retain the ability to remotely program control panels or to open up a two way audio connection to the monitored site then you should carefully consider which of the above mentioned solutions you chose.
It is not possible to open up an audio path using GPRS. It is possible using GSM voice and PSTN, however, both usually attract call charges. You should check that the solutions provider supports both client and server initiated remote programming connections to the panel.
Some control panel manufacturers allow remote programming over the Internet but this method is proprietary and restricted to their particular brand. The preferred universal method is to use an audio connection over the Internet from a solution that incorporates a VoIP ATA as the primary transmission device. Such devices have the ability to reliably transmit alarm signals, allow operators to have two way voice conversations and allow Alarm Companies to remotely program any make of alarm panel over the Internet.
Summary
The cost and availability of the various networks, existing equipment and infrastructure, insurance requirements and other concerns may ultimately determine which solutions you chose to migrate from the analogue to digital world. My hope is that this article has helped cover some of the more technical aspects of the decision making process and makes your transition as smooth as possible.
About the Author
Steve Nutt is the owner of an Internet Alarm monitoring service for both home security and medical alert systems.
Brady Cases Macbook Pro Apple Laptop Mobile Workstation ATA Case w/ iPhone dock
|
|
ATA Case SUPER SALE for MACKIE 24X4 24-4 VLZ PRO MIXER $119.95 |
|
|
Cables To Go 39001 PC CABLE TESTER PRO ATA $188.59 |
|
|
Hitachi GSA S10N IDE/ATA DVD+RW DL Superdrive For Macbook Pro 9.5mm $31.99 |
|
|
AUDIO DYNAMICS PRO ATA SINGLE TURNTABLE DJ CASE FITS 98% OF ALL TURNTABLES NEW $68.10 |
|
|
Pro-Mark ATA2 Tenor Marching Mallets $25.29 |
|
|
XCase Warwick 115 Pro 1×15 Cabinet ATA Road Case 1/4 $298.99 |
|
|
XCase Warwick 115 Pro 1×15 Cabinet ATA Road Case 3/8 $348.99 |
|
|
XCase Warwick 211 Pro 2×10 210 Cab ATA Road Case 1/4 $298.99 |
|
|
XCase Warwick 211 Pro 2×10 210 Cab ATA Road Case 3/8 $348.99 |
|
|
XCase Warwick 410 Pro 4×10 Cabinet ATA Road Case 1/4 $298.99 |
|
|
XCase Warwick 410 Pro 4×10 Cabinet ATA Road Case 3/8 $348.99 |
|
|
XCase Warwick 411 Pro 4×10 410 Cab ATA Road Case 1/4 $298.99 |
|
|
XCase Warwick 411 Pro 4×10 410 Cab ATA Road Case 3/8 $348.99 |
|
|
ATA Medium Duty Carpet Lined CASE for KORG PA1X PRO 76 NOTE KEYBOARD $129.95 |
|
|
Pro-Mark ATA2 Tenor Marching Mallets $25.29 |
|
|
Pro-Mark ATA4 Rubber Tom Mallets $22.49 |
|
|
ATA Medium Duty Carpet Lined CASE for MOTION SOUND PRO3TM AMPLIFIER – New! $129.95 |
|
|
ANALOX ATA PRO TRIMIX ANALYZER – Scuba Dive $694.95 |
|
|
MAC PRO ATA Safe Case™ MAC PRO Rolling Flight Case HD ATA $339.00 |
|
|
AMERICAN DJ ACCU SPOT PRO MOVING HEAD ATA CASE – New! $169.00 |
|
|
AUDIO DYNAMICS PRO ATA flight CD CASE HOLDS CDJ-1000 CDJ-800 SL-DZ1200 $89.45 |
|
|
XCase Engl E112V Pro 1×12 112 Cab ATA Road Case 1/4 $256.00 |
|
|
XCase Engl E112V Pro 1×12 112 Cab ATA Road Case 3/8 $287.00 |
|
|
XCase Engl E212V Pro Slanted 2×12 Cab ATA Road Case 1/4 $298.99 |
|
|
XCase Engl E212V Pro Slanted 2×12 Cab ATA Road Case 3/8 $348.99 |
|
|
ATA Road Case for Fender 115 Pro 1×15 Cabinet Tour-Safe $358.00 |
|
|
ATA Road Case for Fender 210 Pro 2×10 Cabinet Tour-Safe $358.00 |
|
|
ATA Road Case for Fender 215 Pro 2×15 Bass Cabinet Tour-Safe $549.00 |
|
|
ATA Road Case for Fender 400 Pro 2×10 210 Combo Tour-Safe $358.00 |
|
|
ATA Road Case for Fender 400 Pro HD Head Lift Off Tour-Safe $189.99 |
|
|
ATA Road Case for Fender 410 Pro SL 4×10 Cabinet Tour-Safe $399.00 |
|
|
ATA Road Case for Fender 410 Pro ST 4×10 Cabinet Tour-Safe $399.00 |
|
|
ATA Road Case for Fender Bassman 300 Pro Head Lift Off Tour-Safe $243.99 |
|
|
ATA Road Case for Fender Hot Rod Pro Junior 1×10 Combo Tour-Safe $324.99 |
|
|
ATA Road Case for Fender Pro Reverb 1×12 112 Combo Tour-Safe $324.99 |
|
|
ATA Road Case for Fender Pro Reverb Blackface 2×12 Tour-Safe $324.99 |
|
|
ATA Road Case for Fender Pro Reverb Silverface 68-69 Tour-Safe $324.99 |
|
|
ATA Road Case for Fender Pro Reverb Silverface 70-81 Tour-Safe $324.99 |
|
|
ATA Road Case for Fender Roc Pro 1000 Head Amp Tour-Safe $199.00 |
|
|
ATA Road Case for Fender Roc Pro 1000 Head Lift Off Tour-Safe $189.99 |
|
|
12″ Mixer TOV ATA PRO DJ Case w Handle Quality NEW $129.00 |
|
|
12″ Mixer TOV ATA PRO DJ Case High Quality Heavy Duty $129.00 |
|
|
12″ Mixer TOV ATA PRO AUDIO VIDEO DJ CASE BRAND NEW $129.00 |
|
|
TOV PRO ATA Single DJ Flight Ready 10″ 12″ Mixer Case $99.95 |
|
|
NEW 12″ DJ ATA MIXER CASE Fits Pioneer Pro DJ DJM-700K $99.95 |
|
|
NEW 12″ DJ ATA MIXER CASE Fits Pioneer Pro DJ DJM 800 K $99.95 |
|
|
New TOV PRO ATA Single DJ Flight Zone 12″ Mixer Case PA $99.95 |
|
|
New 2.5″ 2nd SATA Serial ATA HDD SSD Hard Drive Caddy Adapter for MacBook Pro $12.00 |
|
|
ECONOMY ATA CASE for BEHRINGER UB2442FX PRO MIXER $119.95 |
|
|
ATA Case SUPER SALE for KORG TRITON PRO 76 KEYBOARD $119.95 |
|
|
OSP Multi-Purpose Pro Audio Utility Road Tour Production Trunk ATA Flight Case $399.99 |
|
|
Pedaltrain PT-Pro Pedalboard & Hardshell ATA Flightcase $299.99 |
|
|
Pedaltrain PT-PRO-HC Pedalboard w/ ATA Flight Case $299.95 |
|
|
Startech Pro ATA133 Cushion Drive Drawer 3.5″ Storage Enclosure DRW115ATABK New $60.90 |
|
|
Pedaltrain Pro Pedal Board w/ATA Hard Case NEW $0 ship $299.99 |
|
|
NEW*** Pro-Mark Cookie Tom Mallets ATA1 1 1/4 Inch Nylon $14.99 |
|
|
For parts Macbook Pro 2.2ghz 15″ A1226 C2D ATA DVD-RW Super Drive UJ-857 $1.00 |
|
|
ELITE CORE OSP ATA-JCM-900 PRO ATA FLIGHT CASE FOR MARSHALL JCM 900 HEAD $269.99 |
|
|
Startech Pro ATA133 Cushion Drive Drawer 3.5″ Storage Enclosure DRW115ATABK New $61.99 |
|
|
ATA Case for Pedaltrain PT-PRO PT-2 Pedaltrain Pro 32″ $129.00 |
|
|
ATA AUDIO DYNAMICS PRO MIXER CASE FOR 19″ MIXER REMOVABLE LID & FREE SHIPPING $99.10 |
|
|
Pro-Mark ATA4 Rubber Tom Mallets $22.49 |
|
|
Pro-Mark ATA2 Tenor Marching Mallets $25.29 |
|
|
Imation PRO 7000 Series 27050 32 GB Solid State Drive – Serial ATA/150 - $133.47 |
|
|
COEMAR PRO WASH 250 MOVING HEAD ATA CASE – Brand New! $169.00 |
|
|
OSP 20 Space 20u 19″ Amp Rackmount Road Tour Pro Sound ATA Flight Case w/Casters $419.99 |
|
|
OSP 8 Space 8u Effects Efx Rack 19″ Mount 14″ Deep Road Tour Pro ATA Flight Case $159.99 |
|
|
Pedaltrain Pro w/ ATA Flight Case $100.00 |
|
|
Pro Sound Audio TT PATCHBAY Touring Rack case TOUR LITTLITE Raklite ATA Flight $150.00 |
|
|
Apple Macbook Pro A1260 15.4″ IDE/ATA Laptop GSA-S10N CD-RW DVD-RW Super Drive $42.99 |
|
|
Hitachi Travelstar 5K100 HTS541060G9AT00 60 GB ATA IDE Intrnal w/ Windows XP PRO $1.29 |
|
|
CABLES TO GO PC CBL TESTER PRO ATA $166.31 |
|
|
16 SPACE AUDIO DYNAMICS PRO ATA EFFECTS 19″ RACK MOUNT FLIGHT DJ CASE BRAND NEW $299.10 |
|
|
AUDIO DYNAMICS PRO ATA 16 U SPACE VERTICAL RACK CASE 20″ DEEP w/ 4″ CASTERS $289.95 |
|
|
AUDIO DYNAMICS PRO 10 SPACE ATA SHOCK MOUNT CASE 20″ DEEP INSIDE AMP RACK $179.20 |
|
|
ELITE CORE OSP ATA-JC-120 PRO ATA FLIGHT CASE FOR ROLAND JAZZ CHORUS JC-120 $269.99 |
|
|
AUDIO DYNAMICS PRO CARRYING ATA CD CASE 300 CD’S SILVER $49.10 |
|
|
ELITE CORE OSP ATA-SUPER-REV PRO ATA FLIGHT CASE FOR FENDER SUPER REVERB AMP $289.99 |
|
|
AUDIO DYNAMIC PRO FLIGHT ATA TURNTABLE CONSOLE DUAL TURNTABLES @ 19″ MIXER SLOT $179.40 |
|
|
AUDIO DYNAMIC PRO ATA DUAL TURNTABLES 19” MIXER COFFIN CASE BLACK WHEELS $229.05 |
|
|
NEW AUDIO DYNAMIC PRO ATA UNIVERSAL TURNTABLE COFFIN CASE 19” MIXER LID TABLE $229.60 |
|
|
AUDIO DYNAMIC PRO 2 TURNTABLE ATA CONSOLE LID LEG COFFIN & STAND RECESSED CASTER $229.45 |
|
|
AUDIO DYNAMICS PRO COFFIN ATA TURNTABLES CONSOLE 2 TURNTABLES @ 19″ MIXER $179.50 |
|
|
AUDIO DYNAMICS PRO ATA 10 SPACE SLANTED MIXER RACK /6 U RACK SYSTEM & SHELF $246.00 |
|
|
ATA 10 U SLANTED MIXER RACK /4 U RACK & LAPTOP SHELF BY AUDIO DYNAMICS PRO DJ $228.25 |
|
|
AUDIO DYNAMIC 12U RACK+11U MIXER SLOT ATA CASE 20″ DEEP W/ 4″ PRO LINE CASTERS $279.50 |
|
|
AUDIO DYNAMIC PRO ATA MIXER AMP RACK CASE 19″ RACK MOUNT 11U MIXER / 8U AMP $205.90 |
|
|
AUDIO DYNAMIC PRO ATA MIXER AMP RACK CASE 11U MIXER / 6U AMP SECTION 20″ DEEP $179.95 |
|
|
AUDIO DYNAMIC PRO MIXER RACK CASE 12U BOTT+11U MIXER SLOT ATA 20″ DEEP $279.10 |
|
|
NEW AUDIO DYNAMICS PRO ATA COMBO 11U MIXER SECTION / 8 U AMPLIFIER 20″ DEPTH $206.15 |
|
|
XCase Two Rock Emerald Pro Head Amp ATA Road Case 1/4 $198.00 |
|
|
XCase Two Rock Emerald Pro Head Amp ATA Road Case 3/8 $229.00 |
|
|
NEW AUDIO DYNAMICS PRO 4U TOP 11 U MIXER 12 U BOTTOM ATA FLIGHT CASE BLACK $347.00 |
|
|
AUDIO DYNAMICS PRO 27 SPACE ATA GLIDE STYLE 19″ PRO AUDIO EQUIPMENT CASE BLACK $345.00 |
|
|
AUDIO DYNAMIC PRO ATA CASE 27 SPACE GLIDE STYLE 19″ COMBO DJ CASE BRAND NEW $336.45 |
|
|
NEW AUDIO DYNAMICS PRO ATA PRO RACK CD CARRYING CASE HOLDS 300 CD’S BLACK $49.50 |
|
|
8 SPACE AUDIO DYNAMIC PRO FLIGHT ZONE ATA MIXER CASE FOR 19″ MIXER REMOVABLE LID $99.60 |
|
|
AUDIO DYNAMICS PRO FLIGHT ZONE ATA 10″ MIXER CASE * HEAVY DUTY *BLACK $85.30 |
|
|
NEW AUDIO DYNAMICS PRO 45 LP ATA RECORD CASE SILVER ONLY $39.99 |
|
|
AUDIO DYNAMICS PRO 19″ RACKMOUNT ATA MIXER CASE SILVER OR BLACK CASE $99.90 |